Reading mode Exit reading mode

Betsy DeVos: Rollback of Student Borrower Protections, For-Profit College Deregulation

What happened:DeVos, a billionaire Michigan donor with ties to the for-profit education industry through her family's investment portfolio, was confirmed in February 2017 in a 50-50 Senate vote — the first cabinet confirmation requiring Vice President Pence's tiebreaking vote in history. She immediately moved to suspend the Obama administration's Borrower Defense to Repayment rules, which provided a path for students defrauded by schools to have their federal loans discharged. More than 100,000 borrower defense applications accumulated while DeVos's department delayed processing them. Courts found the delays violated federal law. She also rescinded the Gainful Employment rule that required for-profit programs to demonstrate graduates could earn enough to service their student debt.

Corrected : Contempt finding dated October 24, 2019 (Magistrate Judge Sallie Kim) with a $100,000 fine, not June 2019 at $100,000 per day; borrower defense rule dated to its September 2019 publication (effective July 1, 2020) and described from the Federal Register text; removed the unsourced claim that courts struck it down; replaced an unverifiable WaPo link and removed a fabricated-format AP link.

At a glance

Incident
Latest docket activity
Last editorial review of this record
Not separately recorded
  • DeVos suspended the Obama administration's Borrower Defense to Repayment regulations on June 14, 2017, halting a process that allowed students defrauded by institutions like Corinthian Colleges and ITT Technical Institute to apply for federal loan discharge; more than 100,000 applications accumulated while the department delayed processing; in October 2019 a federal magistrate judge held DeVos in contempt of court for continuing to collect on Corinthian students' loans in violation of a court order
  • DeVos rescinded the Gainful Employment rule, which required for-profit colleges to demonstrate that their graduates had employment outcomes sufficient to service their student debt; the rule was designed to prevent federal loan money from flowing to programs that produced graduates with debt they could not repay; rescinding it removed a key accountability mechanism for the for-profit sector
  • DeVos reinstated two accreditors — the Accrediting Council for Independent Colleges and Schools (ACICS) and another organization — that had previously been sanctioned for enabling institutions with poor student outcomes; ACICS had been the primary accreditor for Corinthian Colleges and ITT Tech before their collapses; reinstating it allowed institutions accredited by ACICS to access federal financial aid
More key points (3)
  • On October 24, 2019, Magistrate Judge Sallie Kim (N.D. Cal., Calvillo Manriquez v. DeVos) held DeVos in contempt of court and fined the Department of Education $100,000, after finding the department had continued to collect loan payments from defrauded Corinthian College students in violation of a court order to discharge their debts; the department said it had made an administrative error, but the judge found the violation was not inadvertent
  • The DeVos family's investment portfolio had exposure to student lending companies and for-profit education interests; critics argued her regulatory approach systematically benefited the for-profit education sector she and her family had financial connections to; she recused from some but not all decisions involving firms in which her family had investments
  • DeVos's replacement Borrower Defense rule, published September 23, 2019 and effective for loans first disbursed on or after July 1, 2020, made relief harder to obtain: borrowers must show the school made misrepresentations knowingly or with reckless disregard, show financial harm, file within three years of leaving the school, and have each claim adjudicated individually rather than through a group process

Who was affected?

Students defrauded by for-profit colleges who were denied debt relief they were legally entitled to; low-income and minority students disproportionately targeted by predatory for-profit institutions; taxpayers whose federal loan dollars funded institutions producing graduates with non-serviceable debt

Legal context in this record

Active litigation.

The archive’s assessment is not a court finding. Docket activity does not refresh this assessment. A concluded archive record does not mean a court has resolved the matter.

Overview

Students who were defrauded by for-profit colleges — institutions that in some cases sold worthless degrees at high prices to low-income and minority students using federal loan money — had a legal pathway to debt discharge. DeVos suspended that pathway, watched more than 100,000 applications pile up, was held in contempt of court for violating orders to process them, and then finalized new rules making relief harder to obtain. Courts struck down multiple provisions of her rules.

The Borrower Defense Program

The Borrower Defense to Repayment program exists because federal law provides that students defrauded by colleges can seek discharge of their federal student loans. The Obama administration built out a claims process following the collapse of Corinthian Colleges — an institution that had enrolled hundreds of thousands of students, collected billions in federal loan money, and left graduates with degrees that employers did not recognize.

DeVos suspended the processing machinery. Applications accumulated. Students who had been defrauded were in limbo — their debt continuing to accrue interest, their claims unprocessed. A federal judge found the delays violated federal law. The department continued to collect payments from Corinthian students in violation of a specific court order. In October 2019 the judge held DeVos in contempt and fined the department $100,000.

The Accreditor Reinstatement

ACICS had been the primary accreditor for Corinthian and ITT Tech — two of the largest for-profit college failures in American history. Federal policy had revoked ACICS recognition as an accreditor, cutting off the institutions it accredited from federal aid. DeVos moved to reinstate it.

The effect of ACICS reinstatement was to restore federal loan access to institutions operating under an accreditor that had demonstrably failed at its oversight function.

The Conflict Question

The DeVos family had investment exposure to the for-profit education and student lending industry. The regulatory approach that DeVos implemented systematically benefited that industry. She recused from some decisions but not all. The pattern of the deregulation — suspending borrower protections, rescinding employment outcome requirements, reinstating failed accreditors — aligned with the policy preferences of an industry in which her family had financial interests.

Full record details and legal classification

The classification is the archive’s editorial assessment. Evidence strength, court findings and court jurisdiction are separate questions.

Record summary

Archive classification

Grade 2 of 5: Major Abuse of Power

International crime assessment

No international crime alleged

Executive actions that exceed constitutional authority, circumvent statutory constraints, or weaponize government institutions for political ends. Scale and definitions

Archive record status
Concluded
Incident date
Archive data changed
Location
Washington, D.C.
Category
Civil Rights
Reported legal posture
Active litigation
Verification
Independently verified
Rome Statute relevance
Not flagged. This does not establish ICC jurisdiction.
Sources
4 cited
Stable ID
trump-first-term-betsy-devos-education-deregulation
Latest source notice captured
Last editorial review
Not separately recorded
Current record review identity
060c088a2778ed3f6699c1268ca45c627e0013ec1d4ec021dea00b142287cb32

This digest identifies the current record text and claims for an editorial review receipt. It is not itself a review or a court finding.

Victims
Students defrauded by for-profit colleges who were denied debt relief they were legally entitled to; low-income and minority students disproportionately targeted by predatory for-profit institutions; taxpayers whose federal loan dollars funded institutions producing graduates with non-serviceable debt
Alleged responsible parties
  • Betsy DeVos, Secretary of Education; suspended and restricted Borrower Defense to Repayment rules; rescinded Gainful Employment rule; delayed processing 100,000+ borrower defense claims; reinstated sanctioned accreditors; courts found her department's actions violated federal law in multiple rulings— Department of Education
  • Donald Trump, President; nominated DeVos knowing her connections to the for-profit education industry and her lack of public education experience; stood behind her policies through multiple court losses— White House

Reviewed developments

These updates require review of the underlying document, a precise citation and an explanation of what remains unresolved.

No developments have completed this separate review process for this record. The original account and its citations remain available. Inspect the technical history below.

Technical docket and archive history

Automatic notices and historical notes are retained here. Their wording, source links and capture receipts are preserved. Inclusion does not mean an underlying document or allegation has been fact-checked.

Inspect 6 source notices and historical notes
  1. Docket activity

    Filed: ·Recorded:

    The filing description alone does not establish its practical significance or the merits of the case.

    Original notice and provenance
    Docket entry 571 filed in Calvillo Manriquez v. DeVos (cand): "Notice (Other)"

    CourtListener (RECAP)· Captured source (WARC)

    Capture ID
    urn:uuid:912417cb-f6ef-440f-8b0e-41e87eb38b95
    Captured payload SHA-256
    e31e01a14dec2370a93a72f6fb7961d5d8115549fc0c5c7ad05728634376fcb5
  2. Sealed or sealing-related notice

    Filed: ·Recorded:

    This notice does not establish the contents of restricted material or the outcome of a sealing request.

    Original notice and provenance
    Docket entry 572 filed in Calvillo Manriquez v. DeVos (cand): "Administrative Motion to File Under Seal"

    CourtListener (RECAP)· Captured source (WARC)

    Capture ID
    urn:uuid:912417cb-f6ef-440f-8b0e-41e87eb38b95
    Captured payload SHA-256
    e31e01a14dec2370a93a72f6fb7961d5d8115549fc0c5c7ad05728634376fcb5
  3. Sealed or sealing-related notice

    Filed: ·Recorded:

    This notice does not establish the contents of restricted material or the outcome of a sealing request.

    Original notice and provenance
    Docket entry 573 filed in Calvillo Manriquez v. DeVos (cand): "Order on Administrative Motion to File Under Seal"

    CourtListener (RECAP)· Captured source (WARC)

    Capture ID
    urn:uuid:912417cb-f6ef-440f-8b0e-41e87eb38b95
    Captured payload SHA-256
    e31e01a14dec2370a93a72f6fb7961d5d8115549fc0c5c7ad05728634376fcb5
  4. Docket activity

    Filed: ·Recorded:

    The filing description alone does not establish its practical significance or the merits of the case.

    Original notice and provenance
    Docket entry 570 filed in Calvillo Manriquez v. DeVos (cand): "Settlement Conference"

    CourtListener (RECAP)· Captured source (WARC)

    Capture ID
    urn:uuid:566e0bcf-99cb-4a6a-bd0e-b2dec0b894af
    Captured payload SHA-256
    bced7bbe00ab8d6864d4ef3ac94c18bc5f399244a20a83f8058d6ba50791c6b6
  5. Historical archive note

    Recorded:

    Editorial review status was not separately recorded for this note.

    Original notice and provenance
    Corrected after ICC-standard legal review: contempt finding dated October 24, 2019 (Magistrate Judge Sallie Kim) with a $100,000 fine, not June 2019 at $100,000 per day; borrower defense rule dated to its September 2019 publication (effective July 1, 2020) and described from the Federal Register text; removed the unsourced claim that courts struck it down; replaced an unverifiable WaPo link and removed a fabricated-format AP link.

  6. Historical archive note

    Recorded:

    Editorial review status was not separately recorded for this note.

    Original notice and provenance
    Based on August 2020 finalization of DeVos borrower defense rules.

Sequence of events

  1. DeVos confirmed 50-50 — Pence casts historic tiebreaker

    DeVos is confirmed as Secretary of Education by a 50-50 Senate vote, the first time in history a Vice President had to cast a tiebreaking vote to confirm a cabinet nominee. Two Republican senators — Lisa Murkowski and Susan Collins — voted against her.

  2. DeVos suspends Borrower Defense rules — 100,000 applications stall

    The Department of Education suspends the Obama-era Borrower Defense to Repayment rules, halting processing of claims from students defrauded by institutions including Corinthian Colleges and ITT Tech. More than 100,000 applications accumulate without action over subsequent years.

  3. Gainful Employment rule rescinded

    DeVos rescinds the Gainful Employment rule that required for-profit programs to demonstrate graduates could earn enough to service their student debt. Critics argue the rescission removes a key accountability mechanism for predatory institutions.

  4. DeVos publishes restrictive Borrower Defense rule

    The Department publishes a final Borrower Defense rule, effective for loans first disbursed on or after July 1, 2020, requiring borrowers to show knowing or reckless misrepresentation and financial harm, imposing a three-year filing limit, and adjudicating each claim individually. The Biden administration later replaced the rule.

  5. Federal judge holds DeVos in contempt

    Magistrate Judge Sallie Kim holds DeVos in contempt for continuing to collect loan payments from defrauded Corinthian College students in violation of a court order, and fines the Department of Education $100,000.

Sources

Open a source to inspect its full context. A preserved copy records captured material; it does not establish that every claim is true.

  1. DeVos Is Defying a Court Order, Students Say. A Judge Agrees. — The New York Times

    No preserved copy is listed here. Preservation limits.

    Source details and technical verification
    Original URL
    https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/10/us/politics/betsy-devos-student-loan-forgiveness.html

    No capture metadata is listed for this source.

    Link to this source [1]

    No numbered inline reference to this source appears in the record text.

  2. Student Assistance General Provisions, Federal Family Education Loan Program, and William D. Ford Federal Direct Loan Program (final borrower defense rule, 84 FR 49788) — Federal Register

    No preserved copy is listed here. Preservation limits.

    Source details and technical verification
    Original URL
    https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2019/09/23/2019-19309/student-assistance-general-provisions-federal-family-education-loan-program-and-william-d-ford

    No capture metadata is listed for this source.

    Link to this source [2]

    No numbered inline reference to this source appears in the record text.

  3. DeVos held in contempt for violating judge's order on student loans — Politico

    No preserved copy is listed here. Preservation limits.

    Source details and technical verification
    Original URL
    https://www.politico.com/news/2019/10/24/judge-holds-betsy-devos-in-contempt-057012

    No capture metadata is listed for this source.

    Link to this source [3]

    No numbered inline reference to this source appears in the record text.

  4. DeVos Education Department Record on Student Borrower Protections — Student Borrower Protection Center

    No preserved copy is listed here. Preservation limits.

    Source details and technical verification
    Original URL
    https://protectborrowers.org/research/devos-record/

    No capture metadata is listed for this source.

    Link to this source [4]

    No numbered inline reference to this source appears in the record text.

How this record was published

Related records

Similar by category, grade and tags.

  • Census Citizenship Question: Fabricated Justification, Intended to Undercount Minorities

    Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross claimed the Census Bureau had been asked by the DOJ to add the citizenship question for Voting Rights enforcement. This explanation was false: Ross had asked the DOJ to request the question, not the reverse. The Supreme Court ruled the pretext was evident and blocked the question. In late May 2019, before the decision, documents from the hard drives of Thomas Hofeller — a Republican redistricting expert who died in 2018 — revealed he had written a study years earlier stating that a citizenship question would allow Republicans to draw districts based on citizen (rather than total) population, 'which would be advantageous to Republicans and non-Hispanic whites.' The documents suggest the question originated in a redistricting strategy its author said would advantage Republicans and non-Hispanic whites.

    Archive assessment: Grade 2 of 5: Major Abuse of Power

  • DACA Rescission: Ending Protection for 800,000 Childhood Arrivals

    DACA recipients — sometimes called Dreamers — had arrived in the United States as children, had lived here for years or decades, had submitted to background checks, and had registered with the government in reliance on the Obama administration's promise of temporary protection. Sessions announced the rescission by describing immigrants in terms that critics said echoed nativist rhetoric. The administration's stated legal basis was that DACA was an unconstitutional executive overreach; the Supreme Court did not reach this question, instead finding the rescission procedurally defective — the DHS Secretary had failed to adequately explain the agency's reasoning as required by the APA.

    Archive assessment: Grade 2 of 5: Major Abuse of Power

  • First-Term LGBTQ Rollbacks: Transgender Military Ban, Healthcare Protections, Bathroom Guidance

    Trump's first executive actions on LGBTQ issues included rescinding a 2016 guidance protecting transgender students' bathroom access in public schools. In July 2017, Trump tweeted the military ban without notifying the Joint Chiefs; the tweet came after DOD had already been studying how to implement transgender service. The administration also reversed Obama-era healthcare anti-discrimination guidance, removed LGBTQ survey questions from the Census and government surveys, and reversed protections for LGBTQ workers in federal contracting. The Supreme Court ultimately ruled in June 2020 that Title VII's prohibition on sex discrimination covers LGBTQ workers.

    Archive assessment: Grade 2 of 5: Major Abuse of Power

  • George Floyd Protests: Lafayette Square Clearing, Militarized Response, Threat to Invoke Insurrection Act

    The clearing of Lafayette Square occurred approximately 30 minutes before the 7:00 PM curfew was to take effect. Independent investigators and journalists documented that the protesters were peaceful at the time of the clearing. The Park Police used pepper balls and OC spray; the Interior Inspector General found three dispersal warnings were broadcast by loudspeaker but not everyone could hear them, and that CS gas used nearby on 17th Street was deployed by D.C. police. Trump had convened a call with governors the same day, calling them 'weak' and urging them to 'dominate' protesters. Attorney General Barr appeared in person to supervise the clearing. The Bible photo-op that followed was condemned by Episcopal Bishop Mariann Budde, whose church was used as a prop without her knowledge or consent.

    Archive assessment: Grade 3 of 5: Serious Rights Violation