ACA Sabotage: Deliberate Undermining of Health Insurance for Millions
Last updated
Having failed to repeal the ACA legislatively (defeated by the 51-49 Senate vote, including John McCain's thumbs-down), the Trump administration used regulatory and administrative mechanisms to undermine it: eliminating the individual mandate penalty, cutting navigator and outreach funding from $63 million to $10 million, supporting a lawsuit arguing the entire ACA was unconstitutional, and expanding short-term health plans that excluded pre-existing conditions. CBO projected these actions would cause 10-13 million people to lose insurance.
Overview
When Congress failed to repeal the ACA — blocked by a 51-49 Senate vote — the Trump administration adopted a different strategy: administrative sabotage. The goal was the same, but the mechanism was regulatory and administrative action rather than legislation.
The administration was largely successful. Premium increases attributable to the end of cost-sharing reduction payments were documented immediately. Enrollment declined. The number of uninsured Americans stopped falling and began rising.
The Tools of Sabotage
The administration's tools were varied. It cut the budget for helping people navigate enrollment options by 90%. It shortened the enrollment window, reducing the time people had to shop for plans. It stopped advertising enrollment in the final weeks — when advertising had historically been most effective.
It eliminated the cost-sharing reduction payments that kept premiums affordable for low-income enrollees. It expanded alternative "junk plans" that could deny coverage for pre-existing conditions. It refused to defend the ACA in court when a federal judge ruled it unconstitutional.
Each measure individually was defensible as regulatory discretion. Cumulatively, they constituted a deliberate strategy to undermine a functioning health insurance system while a legislative replacement did not exist.
The Casualties
The Congressional Budget Office projected that the elimination of the individual mandate penalty alone would cause 10-13 million people to lose insurance over 10 years. Premium increases attributable to the CSR payment termination were documented in the range of 20% in markets where the administration's action directly drove the increase.
People who lost insurance or who couldn't afford higher premiums delayed or forgone medical care as a result. The attributable effects on health outcomes are difficult to isolate precisely — but the mechanism is well understood: people without insurance get less preventive care, delay treatment for serious conditions, and die at higher rates from preventable causes.
Timeline
Sequence of events
January 20, 2017
Day one executive order — implement 'maximum extent possible'
Trump signs an executive order on Day One directing federal agencies to use 'maximum extent possible' regulatory discretion to waive or delay ACA requirements pending repeal legislation.
July 28, 2017
McCain casts decisive 'no' vote on ACA repeal
The Senate vote to pass the 'skinny repeal' fails 51-49, with Sen. John McCain providing the decisive thumbs-down vote. Trump and administration allies immediately declare intent to pursue non-legislative means to undermine the ACA.
October 12, 2017
Trump ends cost-sharing reduction payments
Trump halts CSR payments to insurance companies — payments that offset the cost of providing reduced out-of-pocket costs to low-income enrollees. Insurers respond by increasing premiums; the CBO projects the action will increase the federal deficit by billions due to larger premium subsidies required.
October 12, 2017
Executive order expands short-term and association plans
Trump signs an executive order directing expansion of short-term health plans (not subject to ACA protections) and association health plans. The plans can exclude pre-existing conditions and offer fewer benefits.
June 1, 2018
Navigator funding cut to $10 million
The administration reduces navigator funding — used to pay people who help consumers understand and enroll in ACA plans — from $63 million to $10 million, cutting consumer assistance capacity by approximately 90% in federally-operated marketplace states.
December 14, 2018
Texas judge rules ACA unconstitutional
A federal judge in Texas rules the entire ACA is unconstitutional due to the elimination of the individual mandate penalty. The Trump administration declines to defend the law in court, instead supporting the ruling. The case eventually reaches the Supreme Court, which upholds the ACA in 2021.
Sources
- ↑ Trump Signs Executive Order on Obamacare, Opening Door to Cheaper, Skimpier Plans — The New York Times
- ↑ Tracking ACA Sabotage — Center on Budget and Policy Priorities
- ↑ Navigators in ACA Marketplace States — Funding Cuts — KFF (Kaiser Family Foundation)
- ↑ CBO: Effects of Eliminating the Individual Mandate Penalty — Congressional Budget Office
- ↑ ACA sabotage — what the Trump administration did and why it mattered — The Associated Press
Verification