Trump SoHo: Fraud Investigation, Investor Losses, DA Charges Dropped
Last updated
Trump SoHo buyers, including an investor group led by Sateesh Bhagat, discovered that marketing materials claiming 60% of units were sold were false — fewer than 15% had been sold. They sued for fraud. The Manhattan DA opened a parallel criminal investigation. In 2012, after Trump lawyers met with DA Vance, the investigation was dropped. Vance later received a $25,000 campaign contribution from Kasowitz's law firm, which he initially kept and later returned; Vance denied it influenced his decision. The Bhagat investor group settled civilly for $3.16 million. The pattern — criminal investigation followed by dropped charges after private meeting — resembled the Bondi situation in Florida.
Overview
Trump SoHo buyers discovered that the marketing materials claiming 60% of units were sold were false — fewer than 15% were sold at the time. They sued. The Manhattan DA opened a criminal fraud investigation. The investigation was dropped after Trump's attorney held a private meeting with the DA.
After the investigation was dropped, the attorney's law firm donated $25,000 to the DA's campaign.
The False Sales Figures
In real estate, a development's sales rate affects whether other buyers commit. If 60% of units are sold, the project appears successful; buyers are more comfortable committing. If 15% are sold, the project looks troubled; buyers hesitate.
The difference between the two figures was the difference between buyers committing and buyers waiting. The misrepresentation was not incidental — it was the mechanism of the fraud.
The Emails
The civil case produced emails and documents showing that Trump family members — including Ivanka Trump and Donald Trump Jr. — received regular reports on actual sales numbers while the marketing materials claimed higher figures. The emails documented knowledge of the gap between what was being said and what was true.
This is what ADA Christian believed was sufficient for charges. The investigation was dropped before charges were filed.
The Pattern
Florida: Attorney General Bondi received a $25,000 Trump Foundation donation while reviewing a Trump University fraud complaint. She declined to join the multi-state investigation.
New York: DA Vance received a $25,000 donation from Trump's attorney's firm after dropping the Trump SoHo fraud investigation.
Both donations came through different mechanisms. Both investigations were dropped. Both amounts were $25,000.
Timeline
Sequence of events
January 1, 2006
Trump SoHo marketed with inflated sales figures
Trump SoHo is marketed to buyers with representations that approximately 60% of units have been sold. Fewer than 15% have actually been sold.
January 1, 2010
Buyers discover fraud — civil lawsuit filed
Buyers, including investor Sateesh Bhagat, discover the misrepresentations and file a civil fraud lawsuit against the Trump Organization and Trump family members.
January 1, 2011
Manhattan DA opens criminal fraud investigation
The Manhattan DA's office opens a parallel criminal fraud investigation based on evidence from the civil case. ADA Christian is assigned to lead the investigation.
June 1, 2012
Investigation dropped after private meeting with DA
After Trump lawyer Marc Kasowitz meets privately with DA Vance, the criminal investigation is dropped. ADA Christian reportedly objects but is not consulted. The Bhagat investors settle the civil case for $3.16 million.
October 26, 2017
New Yorker and NYT publish investigation into dropped case
Investigative reporting reveals the details of the dropped investigation, Kasowitz's meeting with Vance, and the subsequent campaign donation. Vance returns the $25,000.
Sources
- ↑ Trump SoHo: How Trump Fraud Investigation Was Dropped After Private Meeting — The New York Times
- ↑ How Manhattan DA dropped the Trump SoHo fraud investigation — The Washington Post
- ↑ Manhattan DA dropped Trump SoHo fraud case after private meeting — The Associated Press
- ↑ How the Trump Family Members Avoided a Criminal Indictment — The New Yorker
Verification